Popular surnames in Kerry can be the cause of a lot of head scratching when searching for Kerry Ancestors. O’Sullivan, O’Connor, O’Connell, O’Donoghue, Fitzgerald, Stack, McElligott, Murphy, Walsh families are thick on the ground and when these surnames are combined with the traditional naming patterns of sons and daughters, identification of YOUR family can be a bit fraught.
Have I any hints to help you identify the correct family. I have been giving this some thought lately. I have been researching the family of William Walsh who was living in Janesville, Wisconsin in 1860. His descendant Molly had done sterling work going through U.S. records and found a William Walsh living in New York in 1855. This Census stated that William was aged 30, Head of the Household, lived with his wife Honora (20), his son Michael (0) and his mother Joanna (54) Widow, and his brother John (17). While we would have to discount all these ages as only approximate (with the exception of Michael, born in N.Y), we have really good stuff here – William’s mothers’ name and a brother’s name. And most importantly, William’s first son is called ‘Michael’, from which we can almost certainly take it that William’s father’s name was also Michael. See Kerry traditional naming practices. All are ‘Born in Ireland’ with the exception of Michael.
So when Molly started to look in the various census records for Janesville which living U.S, relatives were able to identify as ‘home’, it was easy to find William, Honora and Michael. Mother Joanna and brother John were not in Janesville though. There is a long story here and Molly was able to pinpoint the location of all Joanna’s family in the U.S., but our part was to identify them in Ireland.
Very helpfully Molly had, through DNA testing, got a match in the North Kerry area precisely, but without a local knowledge, she had gone up and down a few one way alleys, even identifying her ancestor in East Cork. Once I had eliminated East Cork we were back on familiar Kerry territory.
Ballydonoghue/Ballybunion/Tullamore were our targets. This is when the fun starts! This particular area of North Kerry is rich in Walshs, particularly the Civil Parish of Galey. Unfortunately no Tithe Applotment records have survived for this parish, but there are 178 Walsh names in the North Kerry Baronies of Iraghticonnor & Clanmaurice. Griffith’s Valuation of 1851 is probably outside our search parameters as we know William and his mother, a widow, are in New York by at least 1855. There are 76 Walsh names occupying land in this parish alone – many of them called the same christian names – William, Edmund, Maurice, Thomas. So how to pinpoint our particular family. Well that was not too difficult as we knew the mother was Johanna and presumably the father was Michael. This was confirmed by the location of baptismal certificates for three of the family. Baptismal records start in Ballybunion in 1830 so we do not have verification of William or Edward’s baptisms.
Family of Michael Walsh/Joanna McCarthy
|15.11.1831||Martin||Tullabeg, Gale||Bartholomew Walsh/Mary Walsh||B’bunion**|
|19.6.1834||John||Tullamore||Wiliam Walsh/Catherine Walsh||B’bunion|
|7.6.1837||Stephen||Tullabeg||Daniel Walsh/Mary Walsh||B’bunion|
My stand out ‘hint’ for sorting out which family is the correct one, is to start with the traditional naming pattern but then concentrate on the mother, her surname and the sponsors at the baptisms, who are usually near relatives of both father and mother. If there are unfamiliar Christian names in the family or unfamiliar surnames in the sponsors, caution is required until positive proof emerges.
There is a sad ending to the story of one of William’s brothers. Joanna placed an advertisement in the Boston Pilot in 1867 looking for her son Stephen:
Joanna was living in New York when she placed the advertisement. A reward of $10 was offered for information. We don’t know if she ever located him or not but in December 2015, Molly Harris says: .’I think I found Stephen’s wife and children living in a mining town in Nevada. https://familysearch.org/ark:/61903/1:1:MDC8-T1Q The occupation of the men on the page is “works in mine.” It is a mining town. We know they last heard from Stephen that he was mining in Nevada. The box is ticked for “married” for the wife, Alice, but I wonder if they meant to tick the box for “widow,” as the men of the other families are present. Or maybe Stephen was just away working somewhere else.
The reason I think it could be Stephen’s family is because: (1.) the second son is named Stephen, (2.) the children’s father was “born in Ireland,” and (3.) there do NOT seem to be ANY other Stephen Walshes in Nevada, in this census or the earlier censuses. I have ordered the death certificate of the son Stephen, to see if his father’s name was Stephen.
 U.S. Federal Census 1860
 New York State Census 1855, Verona, Oneida, New York